Did Barca Disrespect Gündogan?

Just weeks ago, the idea of Barcelona letting go of Ilkay Gündogan would have seemed unthinkable. However, football can change rapidly, and it now appears that the German midfielder may leave the club sooner than expected.

Despite being one of Barça’s most consistent performers last season, Gündoğan’s future now hangs in the balance, largely due to a combination of financial considerations and the emergence of young talents from La Masia. Fans are commenting that Barca didn’t give what he deserves.

Gündogan, who arrived at Barcelona on a free transfer after leaving Manchester City, quickly established himself as a vital presence in the squad. His experience and professionalism brought a serious edge to the team, and he featured in almost every match throughout the 2023/24 season.

However, with a reported weekly salary of $393,634 , only Robert Lewandowski and Frenkie de Jong earned more than him at the club.

Despite his importance, questions have arisen about whether his performance fully justified the club’s significant financial commitment, especially when compared to his brilliant form at Manchester City the season prior.

Barcelona’s famed La Masia academy has been producing a new wave of talent, and the competition for places in midfield has intensified. With players like Gavi, Fermin Lopez, Pedri, Pablo Torre, and others rising through the ranks, the club finds itself in a dilemma.

Hansi Flick, Barça’s current manager, has a wealth of midfield options, making it difficult to guarantee Gündoğan a starting role.

From Gündoğan’s perspective, the possibility of no longer being a first-choice player is a major factor in his decision to leave.

He has always demanded 100% from his teammates, both on and off the pitch, and his leadership in the dressing room is well-known. Yet, the club’s desire to lower its wage bill and the pressure to prioritize homegrown talent could lead to his departure.

Ultimately, this move could signal a return to one of Barcelona president Joan Laporta’s key pillars – a starting XI filled with La Masia graduates. It’s a bold decision, but one that might be necessary as the club looks to secure its financial future while maintaining its identity.

Gündoğan’s exit, though potentially risky, could be seen as part of a broader strategy to balance veteran leadership with youthful energy in a new era for the Blaugrana.