Leeds United marked their Premier League return with a dramatic 1-0 victory over Everton at Elland Road, secured by a controversial late penalty from summer signing Lukas Nmecha.
The decisive moment arrived in the 84th minute when referee Chris Kavanagh pointed to the spot after Anton Stach’s shot struck James Tarkowski inside the box. The Everton captain appeared to have his arms by his side, but VAR upheld the on-field decision despite strong protests from the visitors.
Nmecha , making his Leeds debut, kept his composure and slotted home the winner with just his third touch after coming off the bench. The goal sent Elland Road into raptures but left Everton players and manager David Moyes furious.
“It’s not a penalty. My arm was by my side, there’s nothing unnatural about it,” Tarkowski told Sky Sports. “It’s bizarre and it’s cost us a point.”
Moyes echoed his captain’s frustration, calling the decision “really harsh” and adding: “VAR had a chance to get it right and didn’t.”
Not everyone agreed. Former defenders Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher insisted it was the correct call, arguing Tarkowski had leaned towards the ball.
Leeds boss Daniel Farke admitted he hadn’t reviewed the incident but welcomed the referee’s decision.
“On field, it felt like a penalty. The check was long but if the referee gave it, I hope he was right,” Farke said. “I’m glad I trusted Lukas — he was ice cold.”
The match itself offered few clear chances. Joel Piroe went close early for Leeds, while Everton’s best effort came from Charly Alcaraz, forcing Lucas Perri into a sharp save. New signing Jack Grealish, making his debut for the Toffees after joining on loan from Manchester City, struggled to make an impact in a subdued 25-minute cameo.
Leeds, however, won’t care about the controversy. Their return to the top flight begins with three points, while Everton are left to rue a refereeing call that may dominate discussions long after the final whistle.
Discover more from
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.