Who Should Stay, Who Should Go? A Data-Driven Look at Manchester United’s Core Squad

It’s been another season to forget for Manchester United fans. The Red Devils, once the pride of English football, now look like a shadow of their former selves. With just seven games left in the Premier League, United are sitting in the bottom half of the table, and the dream of European football is slipping away fast.

Their 13th league defeat of the season leaves them seven points behind Bournemouth in 10th place. That’s just one loss short of their worst-ever Premier League record, set last season. Clearly, not much has changed under new manager Rúben Amorim, who replaced Erik ten Hag back in November. And while Amorim signed a contract until 2027, it’s no longer guaranteed that he’ll stick around that long.

The pressure is rising, and the summer transfer window may decide both Amorim’s future and United’s long-term direction. According to reports, as many as 10 first-team players could be shown the door. Some names may surprise you, others, not so much.

Time’s Up for Underperformers

Rasmus Højlund, who came in for a massive £72 million, has scored only eight goals in 40 games this season. Just three in the league. That’s not what you expect from your lead striker. When Harry Maguire, a centre-back, had a higher expected goal (xG) rating in nine minutes than Højlund has in 15 games, it says it all.

Antony, another costly signing, seems to have rediscovered his form at Real Betis while on loan. But his spell at United, five goals and three assists in two and a half seasons, was a disaster. No matter how well he does in Spain, a second chance at Old Trafford isn’t the answer.

Then there’s Andre Onana, who was meant to be the long-term replacement for David de Gea. Instead, he’s made several high-profile errors and has become a liability between the posts. United need a new No. 1, plain and simple.

Big Names, Bigger Problems

Marcus Rashford’s story is another frustrating one. After pushing for a loan move to Aston Villa in January, he’s doing well again, seven goal involvements in 11 games. But Rashford’s form is streaky, and his attitude has raised concerns. If Villa or another club offers around £40 million, United would be wise to let him go.

Mason Mount, signed for £60 million from Chelsea, has struggled with injuries all season. He’s played just nine league games and is nowhere near justifying his £250,000-a-week wages. Amorim may like his profile, but trust in Mount at this stage is a risky gamble.

Time to Move On

Tyrell Malacia was sidelined for 550 days due to injury. Though he’s finding some rhythm again on loan at PSV, he’s unlikely to fit into Amorim’s future plans, especially with Patrick Dorgu now in the squad.

Jadon Sancho, another loaned-out talent, hasn’t done much at Chelsea either. His technical ability is clear, but he lacks the intensity needed for Premier League football. A return to Borussia Dortmund seems like the best option for both parties.

Even Diogo Dalot, one of United’s more regular starters, is now under the scanner. Despite interest from top European clubs, Dalot has never really become the elite right-back United need. If a good offer comes in, the club should consider cashing out.

End of the Road for Veterans

Casemiro has had an incredible career, especially at Real Madrid. But at 33, he’s no longer able to keep up with the pace of English football. With Saudi clubs interested, United should take the opportunity to bring in younger legs and recoup some of their investment.

And finally, Luke Shaw. Talented, yes. But his body has let him down time and time again. He’s played just two league matches this season and only 14 last year. Given his injury record, United may not even find a buyer. If that’s the case, releasing him early might be the only option left.

A New Era Is Needed

For too long, Manchester United have held on to players based on potential, reputation, or past glories. But that approach has failed,again and again.

This summer needs to be different. Amorim must be backed to build a squad in his image, one that is younger, hungrier, and more in tune with modern football. It won’t be easy, and fans may have to accept short-term pain. But without a major clearout and a fresh approach, United’s decline will only continue.

The badge still holds weight, but unless real change comes, the glory days will remain just that, a memory.